Renewal Works

from Forward Movement

Discipleship in Action: What Forms a Disciple?

November 20, 2026

In working with over 400 Episcopal churches, RenewalWorks has data around Episcopalian beliefs and practices as well as best practices for churches focused on spiritual vitality.  We often partner with clergy (or related organizations) interested in using the RenewalWorks findings to benchmark or evaluate their research projects or grants. Recently, Dr. Nicole Walters, Associate Rector at St. Paul’s Episcopal Church in Newnan, GA, used RenewalWorks for her dissertation project focused on contemplative life and congregational renewal. 

You can find more of Nicole's writings here: https://www.nicoletwalters.com/ and read how her dissertation project has shaped her parish priest ministry below.

What Forms a Disciple? How RenewalWorks Confirmed What I Was Discovering in My Research

By The Rev. Dr. Nicole T. Walters

There is a question that has been sitting with me for quite some time: How do we help people become disciples, not simply learn about discipleship?

It's a question that initially grew out of my own experience in congregational ministry and eventually became the central question of my Doctor of Ministry research. Over twenty years of ministry around the world and in conversation with Catholic, Orthodox, and Protestant traditions, I had discovered the profound impact of contemplative life on people’s spiritual formation but saw churches struggling to know how to integrate it into their life together.

I was interested in understanding how Episcopal congregations might move toward greater engagement with contemplative practice. I wasn’t simply interested in what practices congregations offered, but what helped those practices take root, become sustainable, and shape the spiritual lives of a community. I was particularly interested in this question because I sensed a growing hunger for deeper spiritual meaning, alongside a familiar challenge in congregational life. We offer worship, education, service opportunities, fellowship, and a variety of programs, but how do we intentionally cultivate the kind of spiritual formation that helps people grow into a deeper relationship with God?

In many ways, this is also the question at the heart of RenewalWorks. And as I became more familiar with its research and findings, I began to recognize some striking connections with what I was discovering in my own research.

Spiritual Growth is About More Than Participation

One of the things RenewalWorks has helped congregations understand is that spiritual growth doesn't necessarily correlate with how long someone has attended church or how involved they are in its activities. A person can be deeply engaged in congregational life and still be longing for a deeper spiritual connection.

RenewalWorks describes spiritual growth through a four-stage continuum: Exploring, Growing, Deepening, and Life with God in the Center. This framework offers a way to understand spiritual growth not simply as increased religious knowledge or participation, but as an evolving relationship with God that gradually shapes the way we live.

In Footsteps, RenewalWorks identifies several catalysts that contribute to this growth: Scripture, spiritual practices, Eucharist, spiritual community, service, and the heart of the leader. As I spent time with these findings, I recognized that many of these same themes were emerging in my own research. But I was also beginning to ask a slightly different question: What actually helps these things become part of the shared life of a congregation?

What I Discovered in Three Episcopal Congregations

For my dissertation, I conducted a qualitative study involving 19 participants across three Episcopal congregations. I wanted to understand how people experienced contemplative practice and what helped cultivate greater engagement with it.

As I listened to participants describe their experiences, several themes emerged. Spiritual leadership mattered. Practices needed to be accessible. Communal rhythms helped sustain engagement. Also, personal relationships and spiritual accompaniment played an important role in people's spiritual growth.

What became increasingly clear was that contemplative practice was not simply an individual discipline. While personal prayer, silence, stillness, and engagement with Scripture were important, these practices became more deeply rooted when they were supported by relationships, leadership, and intentional structures within the congregation.

In other words, people weren't simply developing private spiritual habits. They were participating in a community that was learning to make room for contemplation as part of its common life. This is where I began to see some particularly meaningful connections with RenewalWorks.

The Heart of the Leader

One of the most significant connections was RenewalWorks' emphasis on the heart of the leader. In Footsteps, the spiritual life of the leader is identified as an important catalyst for the spiritual growth of others. This resonated deeply with what I was hearing in my research. Across the congregations I studied, leaders played a significant role in inviting people into contemplative practice and helping sustain a contemplative orientation within the community.

What stood out to me was that this leadership wasn't simply about introducing new practices or offering another formation program. It was about leaders who embodied the very practices they were inviting others into. Their own spiritual lives, their attentiveness to God, and their willingness to create space for silence, prayer, and reflection helped establish a culture in which others could explore and deepen their own spiritual lives.

This raises an important question for those of us in church leadership: What does it mean to cultivate a contemplative orientation as leaders, rather than simply offer contemplative programs? Perhaps one of the most important things we can do to support the spiritual growth of others is to attend to our own formation. The way we inhabit our leadership, the invitations we extend, and the presence we bring into our communities all contribute to the spiritual environment we help create.

From Individual Practice to Congregational Culture

Another connection emerged around the importance of spiritual practices and Scripture. RenewalWorks identifies personal spiritual practices and engagement with Scripture as important catalysts for growth. My research helped me see how these practices might become more accessible and sustainable when they are woven into the rhythms of congregational life.

Practices such as silence, stillness, Lectio Divina, and communal prayer were formative not simply because they were offered, but because people were given opportunities to encounter them, return to them, and experience them within a supportive community. This is an important distinction. We can encourage people to develop personal prayer lives, but what happens when a congregation begins to make space for prayer and contemplation as part of its shared identity? What happens when silence is no longer an occasional exercise but something a community learns to inhabit together?

I also saw how important relationships were to this process. Spiritual companionship, friendship, and opportunities to share one's experiences helped people remain engaged and grow in their practice. This connects closely with RenewalWorks' emphasis on spiritual community and the importance of relationships that offer guidance and support along the way. Spiritual growth is personal, but it is never merely private. We are formed not only through our individual encounters with God, but through the communities in which we learn to pray, listen, worship, and live together.

What This Means for Congregational Renewal

For me, the conversation between RenewalWorks and my research points toward an important consideration for congregational leaders: spiritual renewal requires more than increased activity. New programs, additional opportunities, and greater participation may all have their place. But if our deeper hope is to cultivate disciples who are growing in their relationship with God, we need to pay attention to the environments in which that growth takes place.

What kinds of practices are we modeling? What rhythms are we creating? Are people being invited into deeper relationships with God and one another? Are there opportunities for spiritual companionship and guidance? And perhaps most importantly, are we creating communities in which spiritual growth is something we intentionally cultivate together?

My research doesn't offer a formula for accomplishing this. Each congregation has its own history, culture, gifts, and challenges. But it does suggest that contemplative practices can become more than individual spiritual disciplines. With intentional leadership, accessible invitations, shared rhythms, and meaningful relationships, they can begin to shape the culture of a congregation.

This is where I see an opportunity for Episcopal congregations in particular. We have a rich contemplative inheritance in our liturgy, sacramental life, prayer traditions, and Anglican spirituality. These are not simply historical treasures to preserve. They are resources that can help us cultivate communities in which people learn to attend to God's presence and grow into the life of Christ.

The Question I Am Still Carrying

Looking back, I see RenewalWorks as helping me recognize the significance of the question I was asking in my dissertation. Its research illuminated the importance of spiritual practices, leadership, and community in the process of spiritual growth. My own research helped me begin to understand what it might look like for congregations to cultivate those conditions together.

Ultimately, I think both point us toward a deeper question about the purpose of congregational life. Are we simply helping people become more involved in church, or are we helping people become more deeply rooted in the life of God?

Perhaps the work of congregational renewal begins when we shift our attention from what we can get people to do to how we might help create the conditions in which people can grow.

And I believe one of the most important places to begin is with ourselves: the spiritual lives we cultivate as leaders, the practices we embody, and the communities we help shape.

The focus should not simply be on how we get people to practice contemplation. It must shift to how we become communities in which people are formed through a shared life of prayer, worship, relationship, and attentiveness to God. That is the question I continue to carry into my own ministry as a parish priest, and one I believe is central to the work of congregational renewal.

The Rev. Dr. Nicole Walters is Associate Rector of St. Paul's Episcopal Church in Newnan, GA.

OLDER POSTS

See more posts

An offering from

Forward Movement
412 Sycamore Street
Cincinnati, OH 45202

© 2026 Forward Movement

Get Updates Sent to Your Email

Subscribe now to have new posts sent straight to your inbox.

Continue reading